There is a lot of confusion about various filters, many different opinions, and several important facts to consider. The first is that a pool can be properly maintained with any of the filter systems available: Sand, Cartridge, or Diatomaceous Earth (DE). Here is a brief description of each type:
Water is pushed through a bed of filter sand and removed through a set of lateral tubes at the bottom.
The filter area of a sand filter is equal to the area of the filter itself.
For example, a 24" filter will have 3.14 square feet of filter area. Only the top 1" of sand is actually used to filter the water. The principle behind this filter is that water is pushed through the filter sand, somewhat like an espresso machine. Dirty water goes in the top and clean water exits out the bottom. As the filter sand becomes plugged with debris from the pool, the pressure increases on the filter and the water flow drops. In order to clean the filter, you just run it in reverse and dump the waste water; this is referred to as “backwashing” the filter.
Once the filter is backwashed, you move to the rinse mode and that repacks the sand and then back to filter. This has to be done manually every few weeks. From a hydraulics standpoint, a backwash valve is typically the most inefficient piece of equipment you can add to a swimming pool system.
Should the sand ever become really dirty, it is easily and inexpensively replaced. In terms of particle size filtered out, sand is the lease effective method as it can allow smaller particles to pass back into the pool.
This one is easy to understand. Water passes though a filter material and the filter captures the debris.
This is just like the water filters used under your sink. Cartridges have much more available area to filter than sand. Most start at 100 square feet, and the majority of the cartridge filters sold are larger than 300 square feet so they don’t clog up as quickly and therefore you touch them less frequently. There are two types of cartridge filters in general. In the first case, there are filters elements that are inexpensive to replace and as such, they don’t tend to last as long. Then there are other filters that have very expensive elements and these last 5 or more years.
In both cases, cartridge filters are designed to run at lower pressure than sand. This puts less back-pressure on the pump and hence you get more flow and turnover for an equivalent pump size. Generally these filters have to be cleaned once or twice a season by simply hosing them off, so you don’t touch them as often. In terms of particle size filtered out, cartridge is somewhere between sand and DE.
Diatomaceous earth is mined and is the fossilized exoskeletons of tiny diatoms. They are used to coat “grids” in the filter housing and act as tiny sieves to remove debris. They are very small and as such can filter out particles as small as 5 microns.
Diatom filter area are sized between sand and cartridge at around 60 to 70 square feet are most common. Once the filter pressure rises, the filter is backwashed just like a sand filter and then “recharged” with more DE powder. Typically it is poured in a slurry into the skimmer and it then coats the filter grids. DE filters run at higher pressures than cartridge filters and as such can lead to some inefficiency and flow loss.
Now with that background, which swimming filter is best? I often use this question to gauge who I am talking to in a pool store. Just ask: “Which swimming pool filter is best” and then listen for the answer. There is only one correct answer to that question: can you please define best? If the answer is any of the three, someone is trying to simply sell you something.
- If you want bulletproof - sand is a great choice.
- Low maintenance would lead one to cartridge.
- The cleanest water might lead you to DE.
- All three types of swimming pool filters work.
- You can add a little DE to a sand or cartridge filter to increases its ability to filter small particles.
- Flocculants can be added to the pool water to create big particles out of small particles (think - flocks of birds are easier to see).
- Cartridges that become fouled can be replaced.
My recommendations? I would go with a high-end cartridge filter for my swimming pool. The reason is that no one really wants to have another item on the to-do list and good cartridge filter can last a season. Be sure that you:
- Plumb a line into the drain port with a ball valve, so that you can bypass the filter when you are vacuuming the pool to waste.
- Use a little DE powder (1 or 2 coffee cans full in the skimmer) to really polish the water or just add a flocculent every now and then.
- Take a look at the filter housing design. You may want to consider how easy the filter is to access and clean.
- Keep in mind that the more square feet of cartridge, the less often you touch it.
- Never use a car wash wand to wash the filter. A hose with a sprayer will work fine.
Happy Swimming! Follow us on Twitter!